Neighborhood Guide · Naperville 60564
Stillwater, Naperville: What Homes Are Selling For
18 single-family homes sold in Stillwater in the last 12 months, averaging $967,000 at 102% of list price. Here’s what that means for your home.
Stillwater at a Glance
The Last 12 Months in Stillwater
Single-family homes sold
18
Average sale price
$967,000
Average sale-to-list
102% of list price
Average market time
25 days
Location
Naperville 60564, Will County
Schools
Indian Prairie District 204, based on recent listings
Sales by Size
Stillwater Single-Family Homes Sold, by Bedrooms
Closed sales in the last 12 months, from the MLS.
4 bedrooms
Sold: 13
Average price: $944,308
Sale-to-list: 102%
Average market time: 32 days
5+ bedrooms
Sold: 5
Average price: $1,026,000
Sale-to-list: 102%
Average market time: 7 days
About the Neighborhood
What Stillwater Owners Should Know
The Neighborhood
Stillwater is a south Naperville neighborhood of larger four- and five-bedroom single-family homes; the homes listed here recently were built in 1999.
It was the busiest of these 15 Naperville neighborhoods, with 18 sales in the last 12 months, and its five-bedroom homes went under contract in about a week on average.
For Sale Now
Homes for Sale in Stillwater
See every home for sale in Stillwater right now, updated daily from the MLS. Save the search to get new listings first.
Jake’s Insider Tip
Pricing a Stillwater Home
“Stillwater homes averaged about $967,000 and sold for 102% of list price, so sellers here have had the upper hand. Five-bedroom homes sold in about 7 days on average. When homes move that fast, the first weekend decides your price, so go to market ready.” See the 229 sales I’ve closed
Thinking of Selling?
Get a Private Pricing Review for Your Stillwater Home
Tell me your address and I’ll send you a realistic price range within 24 hours, based on the closest Stillwater sales to your home. Free, private and no obligation.
Sales data from the MRED multiple listing service: closed sales listed under the Stillwater subdivision name in Naperville, for the 12 months ending October 2026. Averages are across all sales in each group. Zip code, county, school district and year built come from current or recent listings in the subdivision. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Selling in Stillwater: Common Questions
What are homes in Stillwater selling for?
In the last 12 months, 18 single-family homes in Stillwater sold for an average of $967,000. Size, updates and location within the neighborhood move the price a lot, so request a Private Pricing Review for your specific home.
How fast do homes sell in Stillwater?
Single-family homes in Stillwater spent about 25 days on the market on average over the last year and sold for about 102% of list price.
What school district is Stillwater in?
Indian Prairie District 204, based on recent listings. Assignments are set by address, so confirm your home’s schools with the district before you list.
Neighborhood Guides
More Naperville Neighborhoods
Ashwood Creek, Ashwood Park, Cedar Glen, High Meadow, Hobson Village, Knoch Knolls, Moser Highlands, Old Sawmill, River Run, Saybrook, South Pointe, Springbrook Crossing, West Wind, Wildflower. Recent sales, prices by home size and how fast homes sell.